Free shipping on orders over $149
SafeRxPills - Online Pharmacy
These products are intended for personal use only. We are not licensed by the FDA.
Back to BlogMen's Health

Sildenafil vs Tadalafil: Which Works Faster, Lasts Longer and Which Men Prefer

M
Milan Sojitra

Pharmacist and founder of SafeRxPills. Works on generic medicine sourcing and patient-facing drug information for the US, UK, Australian and Canadian markets.

May 18, 202612 min read
Last updated: November 18, 2026
Share:
In this article (12 sections)

Sildenafil and tadalafil work about equally well for erectile dysfunction: a 2017 meta-analysis of 16 head-to-head trials found similar efficacy and similar overall side effect rates. The practical differences are timing and side effects. Sildenafil (Viagra) is taken about 1 hour before sex and has a half-life of about 4 hours; tadalafil (Cialis) improved erections for up to 36 hours in its label trials, is not affected by food and can also be taken once a day.

When men try both, most pick tadalafil: 66% to 73% in four crossover trials. Sildenafil causes more flushing (head to head) and, going by the labels, more color-tinted vision; tadalafil causes more back pain and muscle aches. Below: US label numbers, trial data, the "equivalent dose" question and our prices per tablet as of 17 November 2026. For vardenafil and avanafil as well, see our four-drug ED tablet comparison.

Sildenafil vs tadalafil side by side

Sildenafil (Viagra)Tadalafil (Cialis)
When to take itAbout 1 hour before sex; anywhere from 30 minutes to 4 hours beforeBefore sex (as needed) or once a day at the same time
Peak blood level30 to 120 minutes (median 60 minutes), fasting30 minutes to 6 hours (median 2 hours)
Half-lifeAbout 4 hours17.5 hours
How long it worksNo window stated; may be taken up to 4 hours before sexImproved erections compared with placebo up to 36 hours after a dose
High-fat mealPeak 29% lower and about 60 minutes laterAbsorption not affected by food
Label doses25, 50 or 100 mg; usual start 50 mgAs needed: 5, 10 or 20 mg (start 10 mg). Daily: 2.5 or 5 mg
Daily use option for EDNoYes, 2.5 to 5 mg once a day
Also approved forPulmonary arterial hypertension (as Revatio)Enlarged prostate (BPH), at 5 mg daily; pulmonary arterial hypertension (as Adcirca)
Contraindicated withNitrates or nitric oxide donors in any form; riociguat and other GC stimulatorsOrganic nitrates in any form; riociguat and other GC stimulators
Side effect that stands outFlushing, color tinge to visionBack pain, muscle aches

Sources: Viagra and Cialis US labels, sections 1 to 4 and 12.3.

Which works faster, and which lasts longer

Neither drug causes an erection on its own: both labels say sexual stimulation is needed.

Sildenafil reaches its peak blood level a median of 60 minutes after a dose on an empty stomach, which is why the label suggests taking it about 1 hour before sex. Its half-life is about 4 hours. How long that translates into usable erections is covered in our guide to how long sildenafil lasts.

Tadalafil peaks later, at a median of 2 hours, but it can start sooner than that. In one Cialis label trial, 52% of men on 20 mg reported a successful erection within 30 minutes, against 38% on 10 mg and 35% on placebo. Its half-life of 17.5 hours is what gives the long window: in a 348-man trial, 64% of men on 20 mg had successful intercourse 33 to 39 hours after a dose, against 37% on placebo. More on the 36-hour window: how long does Cialis last.

Grouped bar chart comparing sildenafil and tadalafil. Median time to peak: sildenafil 1 hour, tadalafil 2 hours. Half-life: sildenafil about 4 hours, tadalafil 17.5 hours. Label window between dose and sex: sildenafil up to 4 hours, tadalafil up to 36 hours.
Figure 1. Timing of sildenafil and tadalafil from their US labels. Source: Viagra and Cialis prescribing information.

Food and alcohol

The Viagra label says sildenafil may be taken with or without food, but a high-fat meal slows it: the peak level was 29% lower and arrived about 60 minutes later. Tadalafil's absorption is not changed by food at all. If you usually take a tablet after dinner, this matters.

Bar chart of the effect of a high-fat meal on peak blood level: sildenafil 29% lower with the peak about 1 hour later; tadalafil not affected by food.
Figure 2. Effect of a high-fat meal on each drug. Source: Viagra label section 12.3; Cialis label sections 2.5 and 12.3.

On alcohol, the Cialis label warns that 5 or more units with tadalafil can increase the chance of a faster heart rate, lower standing blood pressure, dizziness and headache. For sildenafil, our guide to taking sildenafil safely covers alcohol and other interactions.

Does sildenafil get you harder than tadalafil?

No trial shows a clear difference in erection quality. In the 2017 meta-analysis of 16 direct comparison trials (Gong and colleagues), the pooled difference in the erectile function score, from the 3 trials that reported it, was 0.03 points (95% CI minus 0.32 to 0.39): no meaningful difference.

In a 291-man crossover trial in which men tried both drugs at their best dose (Eardley 2005), the erectile function score was 23.9 on sildenafil and 24.3 on tadalafil, a difference that was not statistically significant. Successful intercourse was slightly higher on tadalafil (77% of attempts vs 72%). Hardness itself was not measured head to head, so claims that one drug makes erections firmer are not supported.

Do most men prefer Viagra or Cialis?

In each crossover trial we checked, most men chose tadalafil after trying both. Trying both is not the same as taking both at once: see can you take Viagra and Cialis together for the label wording and timing.

TrialMen analyzedDoses comparedChose tadalafilChose sildenafil
Govier 2003, double-blind19020 mg vs 50 mg66.3%33.7%
von Keitz 2004, double-blind18120 mg vs 50 mg (sildenafil increase allowed in some men)73%27%
Eardley 2005, open-label29110 or 20 mg vs 25, 50 or 100 mg71%29%
Bai 2015, open-label, China35020 mg vs 100 mg69.1%30.9%
Grouped bar chart of treatment choice after trying both drugs in four separate crossover trials. Govier 2003 (tadalafil 20 mg vs sildenafil 50 mg): 66.3% chose tadalafil, 33.7% sildenafil. von Keitz 2004 (20 mg vs 50 mg): 73% tadalafil, 27% sildenafil. Eardley 2005 (doses titrated): 71% tadalafil, 29% sildenafil. Bai 2015 (20 mg vs 100 mg): 69.1% tadalafil, 30.9% sildenafil.
Figure 3. Which drug men chose after trying both, in four separate crossover trials. Source: PubMed abstracts of each trial.

Partners lean the same way. In a study of 100 couples (Conaglen 2008), 79.2% of the women preferred their partner's use of tadalafil and 15.6% preferred sildenafil, citing feeling more relaxed and less pressured. Pooled across 9 trials, the odds ratio for men preferring tadalafil was 8.04 (95% CI 4.99 to 12.96).

Why is tadalafil preferred? In the Bai trial the most common reason was getting an erection long after taking the tablet. Still, about 3 in 10 men chose sildenafil.

Is tadalafil 10 mg equivalent to sildenafil 50 mg?

There is no official dose conversion. Neither the Viagra nor the Cialis label gives one, and we found no regulator or guideline table that does. What the labels do give is the usual starting point for each drug: sildenafil 50 mg and tadalafil 10 mg as needed. Both labels then allow one step up (100 mg and 20 mg) or down (25 mg and 5 mg).

Is 100 mg of Viagra the same as 20 mg of Cialis? They are the label maximums for each drug, not equal doses. The trials that compared them used different pairings: tadalafil 20 mg against sildenafil 50 mg in two trials and against 100 mg in another. They measured preference, not equal strength. If you switch, the usual approach is to start at the other drug's standard starting dose and adjust, with a prescriber.

Side effects compared

Head to head, the overall rate of side effects was similar (odds ratio 1.09, 95% CI 0.89 to 1.34, pooled from 5 trials; not significant). The pattern differs: tadalafil caused less flushing but more back pain and muscle aches.

Forest plot of side effects, tadalafil vs sildenafil, odds ratios with 95% confidence intervals: flushing 0.39 (0.27 to 0.54), nasal congestion 0.69 (0.45 to 1.06), nasopharyngitis 0.93 (0.52 to 1.67), headache 0.97 (0.79 to 1.19), any side effect 1.09 (0.89 to 1.34), indigestion 1.41 (0.98 to 2.03), back pain 1.79 (1.06 to 3.02), muscle aches 4.89 (1.66 to 14.43). Flushing, back pain and muscle aches were statistically significant.
Figure 4. Side effects of tadalafil compared directly with sildenafil in a meta-analysis of 16 trials. Source: PMID 28741090.

Label trials (separate programs, so compare each drug with its own placebo):

Side effectSildenafil 50 mgSildenafil 100 mgIts placeboTadalafil 10 mgTadalafil 20 mgIts placebo
Headache21%28%7%11%15%5%
Flushing19%18%2%3%3%1%
Indigestion9%17%2%8%10%1%
Abnormal vision2%11%1%not listednot listed
Nasal congestion4%9%2%3%3%1%
Back pain4%4%2%5%6%3%
Muscle aches2%4%1%4%3%1%

Sources: Viagra label Table 1 (fixed-dose studies); Cialis label Table 1 (as-needed studies).

The vision effect has a reason. Sildenafil is about 10 times more potent at PDE5 than at PDE6, an enzyme in the retina; tadalafil is 700 times more potent. Tadalafil's back pain usually started 12 to 24 hours after a dose and typically went within 48 hours, according to its label.

Who should not take either

  • Nitrates: both are contraindicated with nitrates in any form, including "poppers". After tadalafil, the label says at least 48 hours should pass before a nitrate is considered in a life-threatening emergency. After sildenafil, the label says it is unknown when nitrates can be given safely.
  • Riociguat: "Do not use" either drug with a guanylate cyclase stimulator such as riociguat.
  • Heart disease: ED treatments "should not be used" (Cialis label) or "should not be generally used" (Viagra label) in men for whom sexual activity is inadvisable because of their heart condition.
  • Alpha blockers: be stable on the alpha blocker first; start sildenafil at 25 mg, or tadalafil at its lowest dose.
  • Ritonavir: sildenafil maximum 25 mg in 48 hours; tadalafil maximum 10 mg once every 72 hours as needed.
  • Together: combining them has not been studied. The Viagra label says such combinations are not recommended; the Cialis label says not to take it with other PDE5 inhibitors. A one-tablet mix is covered in our Sildalist guide.
  • Emergencies: get help for an erection over 4 hours or sudden loss of vision or hearing.

Why you might not stay hard on either

Common reasons are no sexual stimulation, or poor timing: sildenafil after a heavy meal, or tadalafil less than 30 minutes before sex. Another is staying on a starting dose when the label allows a step up. If neither drug works at the label maximum when taken correctly, see a doctor; our guide to ED treatment when tablets don't work covers the next options.

Price per tablet: our sildenafil and tadalafil generics

These are Indian generic brands with the same active ingredients as Viagra and Cialis (see our generic Viagra and generic Cialis guides), but they are not FDA-approved products. Prices as of 17 November 2026, smallest and largest pack:

ProductIngredientSmallest packPer tabletLargest packPer tablet
Cenforce 50mgSildenafil 50 mg90 for $71.00$0.79300 for $179.00$0.60
Cenforce 100mgSildenafil 100 mg30 for $35.00$1.17300 for $213.00$0.71
Kamagra 100mgSildenafil 100 mg60 for $61.00$1.02240 for $167.00$0.70
Lovento 100mgSildenafil 100 mg100 for $70.00$0.701000 for $500.00$0.50
Vidalista 2.5mgTadalafil 2.5 mg90 for $59.00$0.66300 for $145.00$0.48
Vidalista 5mgTadalafil 5 mg90 for $63.00$0.70300 for $156.00$0.52
Vidalista 10mgTadalafil 10 mg90 for $71.00$0.79300 for $179.00$0.60
Vidalista 20mgTadalafil 20 mg90 for $84.00$0.93300 for $216.00$0.72
Actilis 20mgTadalafil 20 mg100 for $85.00$0.85300 for $192.00$0.64

At the usual starting doses, sildenafil 50 mg and tadalafil 10 mg cost the same per tablet here ($0.79 in a 90 pack). For Tadalista vs Cialis, see our Tadalista vs Cialis comparison. US pharmacy prices for the brands and generics are in our brand vs generic price guide.

Importing: the FDA states that "in most circumstances, it is illegal for individuals to import drugs or devices into the U.S. for personal use" (FDA personal importation). Check the rules that apply to you.

Which one to choose

  • Sildenafil suits planned sex, men who want the drug out of their system sooner, and men who get back pain on tadalafil. Take it on an empty or light stomach.
  • Tadalafil suits less predictable timing, taking it with meals, men bothered by flushing or vision tint on sildenafil, and men who also have prostate symptoms (daily 5 mg). More on that in our tadalafil for ED and BPH guide.
  • Not sure: trying each for a few weeks, with a prescriber, is what the preference trials did.

References

  1. Viagra prescribing information (Viatris Specialty LLC, revised 11/2023), DailyMed setid d905dc8d-917f-4ea3-a4ee-a1ecf6967d4e.
  2. Cialis prescribing information (Eli Lilly), DailyMed setid bcd8f8ab-81a2-4891-83db-24a0b0e25895, SPL effective 3 June 2026.
  3. Gong B, et al. Int Urol Nephrol 2017. Meta-analysis, PMID 28741090.
  4. Preference trials: Govier, Clin Ther 2003 (PMID 14693299); von Keitz, Eur Urol 2004 (PMID 15041116); Eardley, BJU Int 2005 (PMID 16287454); Bai, Asian J Androl 2015 (PMID 25370206); Conaglen, J Sex Med 2008 (PMID 18312284).

?Frequently Asked Questions

Is tadalafil better than sildenafil?

Neither works better overall. A 2017 meta-analysis of 16 head-to-head trials (PMID 28741090) found similar efficacy and similar overall side effect rates. Tadalafil lasts longer, is not affected by food and can be taken daily, and most men preferred it in crossover trials. Sildenafil acts for a shorter time and causes less back pain and muscle aching.

Which works faster, sildenafil or tadalafil?

Sildenafil reaches its peak blood level sooner: a median of 60 minutes on an empty stomach, against 2 hours for tadalafil. Tadalafil can still work early: in a Cialis label trial, 52% of men on 20 mg had a successful erection within 30 minutes, against 35% on placebo. A high-fat meal delays sildenafil by about an hour but does not affect tadalafil.

Is 100 mg of Viagra the same as 20 mg of Cialis?

No. They are the maximum label doses of two different drugs, not equal doses, and no official conversion between them exists. The usual starting doses are sildenafil 50 mg and tadalafil 10 mg as needed, each adjusted up or down by a prescriber.

Why is tadalafil preferred over sildenafil?

Mainly because it lasts longer. In crossover trials 66% to 73% of men chose tadalafil after trying both, and the most reported reason in one trial was being able to get an erection long after taking the tablet. Its absorption is also not affected by food, and it causes less flushing.

Which is safer, sildenafil or tadalafil?

Their overall side effect rates were similar in head-to-head trials, and both carry the same key warnings: never with nitrates or riociguat, care with alpha blockers, and urgent help for an erection over 4 hours or sudden vision or hearing loss. Tadalafil causes more back pain and muscle aches; in its label studies these usually started 12 to 24 hours after a dose and typically resolved within 48 hours.

Can I take sildenafil and tadalafil together?

Not without a prescriber's advice. The combination has not been studied. The Viagra label says such combinations are not recommended because they may further lower blood pressure, and the Cialis label says not to take it with other PDE5 inhibitors.

Is tadalafil the same as Cialis?

Tadalafil is the active ingredient in Cialis, and sildenafil is the active ingredient in Viagra. Generic versions contain the same ingredient. Generic tablets sold as Indian brands such as Vidalista or Cenforce contain these ingredients but are not FDA-approved products.

M

Milan Sojitra

Founder, SafeRxPills, B.Pharm, Rajiv Gandhi University

Pharmacist and founder of SafeRxPills. Works on generic medicine sourcing and patient-facing drug information for the US, UK, Australian and Canadian markets.

More articles by Milan Sojitra

Comments (0)

Leave a Comment

No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!